| The common
ancestor of camels and llamas, Procamelus, evolved in North America
around 11 million to 14 million years ago, and its descendants migrated
to Asia and Africa where they eventually developed into modern camels.
The ancestor of the guanaco entered South America by way of the newly formed
isthmus of Panama some 5 million years ago. Geneticists estimate
the minimum divergence time between the Asian and American camelids at
about 11 million years.
"A camel is six times
the size of the wild guanaco mother, but the baby was the size of a normal
guanaco calf," says Short. |
.
|
Tiger quolls (Dasyurus
maculatus). Could females of this species prove to be suitable
surrogate mothers for artificially produced thylacine embyos?
|
|
"The mother's system
somehow overrides any tendency to produce a huge baby. But since
the hybrid was born, it has grown like a rocket - it's already much bigger
than the mother."
Embryo size probably
wouldn't be a problem if a quoll or Tasmanian devil served as a surrogate
mother to a thylacine embryo. All large marsupials, including thylacines,
are born no larger than about 2.5 cm (1 in.) in size - although pouch space
could prove to be an issue later.
However, there would
remain other intimidating difficulties to creating a viable thylacine embryo.
Short says that even though they have made hundreds of attempts, scientists
have yet to achieve successful interspecific clones between distantly related
animals such as sheep, cattle and pigs.
Even when nuclei are
taken from fresh cells of living animals, they fail to develop in the host
oocytes - the nuclei of sheep, for instance, refuse to develop in cow or
pig oocytes, and vice-versa. Short believes that it would be far
more difficult to clone nuclei obtained from dehydrated thylacine cells
into quoll or Tasmanian devil oocytes.
.
|
One of five preserved
thylacine pouch young in the collection of the Tasmanian
Museum and Art Gallery, Hobart. This male was about three
months old when collected, and thus has only a sparse amount of hair.
|
|
Professor
Alan Trounson, pioneering IVF (In Vitro Fertilization) researcher of Monash
University, believes that cloning of the thylacine will be "basically impossible"
using science's current level of technological development. "When
you pickle something in alcohol, it displaces all the water in the tissue,
and you can't rehydrate it," said Trounson. "But then, I didn't think
they would be able to clone Dolly the sheep, so what do I know?"
Ethyl alcohol preserves
tissue and genes, but in doing so, water, the very substance which is vital
to life, is expelled. Researchers would need to rehydrate not only
the DNA in the thylacine nuclei, but the entire matrix of nuclear proteins
and enzymes that maintains its structure, and conducts its orderly replication
as the cell divides and multiplies. Therefore, more is needed than
just the coded instructions for how to build a thylacine. Obtaining
the complete package of necessary biochemical components will be the determining
factor in whether thylacine cloning is a success or failure.
Trounson is less discouraged
about the prospect of Japanese researchers which may eventually succeed
in resurrecting a Woolly mammoth Mammuthus primigenius - or at least,
a hybrid between the mammoth and its close relative, the Indian elephant,
Elephas
gigas.
Hopefully, some male
mammoth which was quickly frozen in Siberian permafrost around 10,000 years
ago could provide viable, dehydrated sperm that could be revived - as is
the case with sperm stored in liquid nitrogen - to fertilize an egg from
an Indian elephant. It is speculated that the elephant would prove
to be an ideal surrogate mother. Presumably a descendant of early
mammoths, it is genetically more similar to the woolly mammoth than a guanaco
is to a camel. |
Trounson believes that
advancements in technology might allow scientists several hundred years
from now to reconstruct a thylacine from scratch. With existing technologies,
it should be rather routine to clone the entire genetic program of the
thylacine and keep it in storage until the technology is ready. The
thyacine's blueprint would be preserved as an array of overlapping DNA
sequences spliced into the chromosomes of
E. coli bacteria, and
indefinitely maintained as a self-perpetuating "DNA library". |